-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 13
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Update saber submodule #163
Comments
The five mpas-jedi ctests are still failing with a reference mismatch error after updating Saber to the latest commit. It turns out that the reference files for mpas-jedi ctests are generated with CRTMv3 (RDASApp uses v2.4). This might explain why all the failing tests assimilate amsua data. There are some tests that pass with amsua data, though the differences might just be smaller than the float relative tolerance. I am trying to confirm by updating to CRTMv3 and see if the ctests pass now, but the build is very slow due to needing to download the updated CRTM coefficients. |
Great find! @SamuelDegelia-NOAA This poses another issue: do we want to upgrade to use CRTMv3? I think we should. |
One potential issue with using CRTMv3 is that cross-validation against GSI might be harder. I am not sure if GSI is able to use CRTMv3 yet (or if it matters). But I'll tag @ShunLiu-NOAA, @xyzemc, @TingLei-NOAA if they want to provide other thoughts. |
I don't think CRTMv3 is ready at this moment. As I know, global still keep using crtm2.4.0 for both GSI and JEDI. |
We had discussion of the version of crtm. We have to stay with the version that used in GDASApp so that we can test satellite DA in RDASApp. |
@xyzemc Could you test the latest RDASApp to see whether the radiance DA works? |
Updating Saber and CRTM (to v3) allows four of the previously-failing ctests to pass. The GETKF test still fails but I will further investigate this tomorrow.
Even though we plan to not update to CRTMv3 yet, it is good to know why those four tests were failing and that it is for an acceptable reason. |
Now that Saber #928 has been merged, we can update that submodule in RDASApp. I will work on a PR for this. This will also (hopefully) resolve the ctest failures reported in #158.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: