Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

SCL edits with the Ace editor cause namespace problems #9

Open
danyill opened this issue Nov 26, 2024 · 0 comments
Open

SCL edits with the Ace editor cause namespace problems #9

danyill opened this issue Nov 26, 2024 · 0 comments

Comments

@danyill
Copy link

danyill commented Nov 26, 2024

I made some changes to descriptions using the Ace editor today.

I was surprised to find that it appears to have inlined the namespaces on all elements which was not desired as well as introduce additional whitespace/formatting.

Just a think to be aware of!

diff --git a/sel-411l-2-line-protection/settings/SEL-411L-2.icd b/sel-411l-2-line-protection/settings/SEL-411L-2.icd
index f60fa40..1669222 100644
--- a/sel-411l-2-line-protection/settings/SEL-411L-2.icd
+++ b/sel-411l-2-line-protection/settings/SEL-411L-2.icd
@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
-<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
-<SCL xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" version="2007" revision="B" xmlns="http://www.iec.ch/61850/2003/SCL">
+<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
+<SCL xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" xmlns="http://www.iec.ch/61850/2003/SCL" version="2007" revision="B">
 	<Header id="New Project" version="0" revision="1.0" toolID="AcSELerator Architect 2.3.16.143" nameStructure="IEDName">
 		<History>
 			<Hitem version="0" revision="1.0" when="11/26/2024 22:12:04" who="AzureAD\MaikUfferhardt" what="IED exported from Project New Project"/>
@@ -131,7 +131,8 @@
 			<esel:System controllableModeSupported="true"/>
 		</Private>
 		<Private type="SEL_HostFile">
-      <esel:host_file path="SETTINGS\" filename="SET_LCC.TXT" allowRemoval="false"><![CDATA[[LCC]
+			<esel:host_file path="SETTINGS\" filename="SET_LCC.TXT" allowRemoval="false">
+				<![CDATA[[LCC]
 		"PROTSEL1","CSV01 := DSTRT OR NSTRT"
 		"PROTSEL2","CSV02 := BFI3P1 OR BFIA1 OR BFIB1 OR BFIC1"
 		"PROTSEL3","CSV03 := BFI3P2 OR BFIA2 OR BFIB2 OR BFIC2"
@@ -163,7 +164,8 @@
 		"PROTSEL29",""
 		"PROTSEL30",""
 		"PROTSEL31",""
-		"PROTSEL32",""]]></esel:host_file>
+		"PROTSEL32",""]]>
+			</esel:host_file>
 		</Private>
 		<Private type="SEL_OriginatorAccess">
 			<esel:Originator category="0" allowed="0"/>
@@ -205,7 +207,7 @@
 		<AccessPoint desc="Station Bus" name="S1">
 			<Server>
 				<Authentication/>
-        <LDevice desc="Data Sets, Control Blocks, and Supervision Logical Nodes" inst="CFG">
+				<LDevice xmlns="http://www.iec.ch/61850/2003/SCL" desc="Data Sets, Control Blocks, and Supervision Logical Nodes" inst="CFG">
 					<LN0 lnType="LN0_Root_Cmb_2" lnClass="LLN0" inst="">
 						<DataSet desc="For Transpower test technicians. Mapped to GOOSE." name="Test">
 							<FCDA ldInst="ANN" prefix="TLED" lnClass="GGIO" lnInst="7" doName="Ind03" daName="stVal" fc="ST"/>
@@ -522,25 +524,25 @@
 							</DAI>
 						</DOI>
 						<DOI name="Loc">
-              <DAI esel:datasrc="db:LOC" name="stVal" />
+							<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="db:LOC" name="stVal"/>
 						</DOI>
 						<DOI name="LocSta">
 							<SDI name="Oper">
-                <DAI esel:datasrc="db:LOCSTA" name="ctlVal" />
+								<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="db:LOCSTA" name="ctlVal"/>
 							</SDI>
-              <DAI esel:datasrc="db:LOCSTA" name="stVal" />
+							<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="db:LOCSTA" name="stVal"/>
 							<DAI name="ctlModel">
 								<Val>sbo-with-enhanced-security</Val>
 							</DAI>
-              <DAI esel:datasrc="imm" name="sboTimeout">
+							<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="imm" name="sboTimeout">
 								<Val>10000</Val>
 							</DAI>
-              <DAI esel:datasrc="imm" name="stSeld">
+							<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="imm" name="stSeld">
 								<Val>false</Val>
 							</DAI>
 						</DOI>
 						<DOI name="MltLev">
-              <DAI esel:datasrc="db:MLTLEV" name="setVal" />
+							<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="db:MLTLEV" name="setVal"/>
 						</DOI>
 						<Inputs>
 							<ExtRef desc="IAW (Line CB current)" intAddr="IAW" serviceType="SMV"/>
@@ -610,7 +612,7 @@
 						</Inputs>
 						<GSEControl desc="Trip, Close, CBF and ARecl signals" name="Ctl" datSet="Ctl" confRev="1" appID="Ctl">
 							<Private type="SEL_GOOSETXAddress">
-                <esel:Address>
+								<esel:Address xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850">
 									<esel:P type="MAC-Address">01-0C-CD-01-00-03</esel:P>
 									<esel:P type="APPID">0001</esel:P>
 									<esel:P type="VLAN-ID">06E</esel:P>
@@ -618,15 +620,15 @@
 								</esel:Address>
 							</Private>
 							<Private type="SEL_GOOSETXMinTime">
-                <esel:MinTime>4</esel:MinTime>
+								<esel:MinTime xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850">4</esel:MinTime>
 							</Private>
 							<Private type="SEL_GOOSETXMaxTime">
-                <esel:MaxTime>1000</esel:MaxTime>
+								<esel:MaxTime xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850">1000</esel:MaxTime>
 							</Private>
 						</GSEControl>
 						<GSEControl desc="GOOSE messages between P1 line protection relays of separate primary busses in 1.5 CB applications." name="CtlHalfCB" datSet="CtlHalfCB" confRev="1" appID="HalfCB">
 							<Private type="SEL_GOOSETXAddress">
-                <esel:Address>
+								<esel:Address xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850">
 									<esel:P type="MAC-Address">01-0C-CD-01-00-04</esel:P>
 									<esel:P type="APPID">0002</esel:P>
 									<esel:P type="VLAN-ID">3EE</esel:P>
@@ -634,15 +636,15 @@
 								</esel:Address>
 							</Private>
 							<Private type="SEL_GOOSETXMinTime">
-                <esel:MinTime>4</esel:MinTime>
+								<esel:MinTime xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850">4</esel:MinTime>
 							</Private>
 							<Private type="SEL_GOOSETXMaxTime">
-                <esel:MaxTime>1000</esel:MaxTime>
+								<esel:MaxTime xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850">1000</esel:MaxTime>
 							</Private>
 						</GSEControl>
 						<GSEControl desc="For Transpower test technicians." name="Test" datSet="Test" confRev="1" appID="Test">
 							<Private type="SEL_GOOSETXAddress">
-                <esel:Address>
+								<esel:Address xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850">
 									<esel:P type="MAC-Address">01-0C-CD-01-00-05</esel:P>
 									<esel:P type="APPID">0005</esel:P>
 									<esel:P type="VLAN-ID">06E</esel:P>
@@ -650,15 +652,15 @@
 								</esel:Address>
 							</Private>
 							<Private type="SEL_GOOSETXMinTime">
-                <esel:MinTime>4</esel:MinTime>
+								<esel:MinTime xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850">4</esel:MinTime>
 							</Private>
 							<Private type="SEL_GOOSETXMaxTime">
-                <esel:MaxTime>1000</esel:MaxTime>
+								<esel:MaxTime xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850">1000</esel:MaxTime>
 							</Private>
 						</GSEControl>
 						<GSEControl desc="Interlocking status messages to the central interlocking controller" name="ILock1" datSet="ILock1" confRev="1" appID="ILock1">
 							<Private type="SEL_GOOSETXAddress">
-                <esel:Address>
+								<esel:Address xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850">
 									<esel:P type="MAC-Address">01-0C-CD-01-00-06</esel:P>
 									<esel:P type="APPID">0006</esel:P>
 									<esel:P type="VLAN-ID">3EE</esel:P>
@@ -666,13 +668,13 @@
 								</esel:Address>
 							</Private>
 							<Private type="SEL_GOOSETXMinTime">
-                <esel:MinTime>4</esel:MinTime>
+								<esel:MinTime xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850">4</esel:MinTime>
 							</Private>
 							<Private type="SEL_GOOSETXMaxTime">
-                <esel:MaxTime>1000</esel:MaxTime>
+								<esel:MaxTime xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850">1000</esel:MaxTime>
 							</Private>
 						</GSEControl>
-            <SettingControl esel:activeGroupLabel="ACTGRP" esel:numberOfSettingGroupsLabel="MAXGRP" numOfSGs="6" />
+						<SettingControl xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:activeGroupLabel="ACTGRP" esel:numberOfSettingGroupsLabel="MAXGRP" numOfSGs="6"/>
 					</LN0>
 					<LN lnType="LPHD2" prefix="DevID" lnClass="LPHD" inst="1">
 						<DOI name="Proxy">
@@ -682,99 +684,99 @@
 						</DOI>
 						<DOI name="Sim">
 							<SDI name="Oper">
-                <DAI esel:datasrc="db:LPHDSIM" name="ctlVal" />
+								<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="db:LPHDSIM" name="ctlVal"/>
 							</SDI>
-              <DAI esel:datasrc="db:LPHDSIM" name="stVal" />
+							<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="db:LPHDSIM" name="stVal"/>
 							<DAI name="ctlModel">
 								<Val>sbo-with-enhanced-security</Val>
 							</DAI>
-              <DAI esel:datasrc="imm" name="sboTimeout">
+							<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="imm" name="sboTimeout">
 								<Val>10000</Val>
 							</DAI>
-              <DAI esel:datasrc="imm" name="stSeld">
+							<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="imm" name="stSeld">
 								<Val>false</Val>
 							</DAI>
 						</DOI>
 					</LN>
 					<LN lnType="LCCH_PB_2" prefix="PB" lnClass="LCCH" inst="1">
 						<DOI name="ChLiv">
-              <DAI esel:datasrc="db:PBCH" name="stVal" />
+							<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="db:PBCH" name="stVal"/>
 						</DOI>
 						<DOI name="RedChLiv">
-              <DAI esel:datasrc="db:PBRCH" name="stVal" />
+							<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="db:PBRCH" name="stVal"/>
 						</DOI>
 						<DOI name="RxCnt">
-              <DAI esel:datasrc="db:PBRX" name="actVal" />
+							<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="db:PBRX" name="actVal"/>
 							<DAI name="pulsQty">
 								<Val>1</Val>
 							</DAI>
 						</DOI>
 						<DOI name="RedRxCnt">
-              <DAI esel:datasrc="db:PBRRX" name="actVal" />
+							<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="db:PBRRX" name="actVal"/>
 							<DAI name="pulsQty">
 								<Val>1</Val>
 							</DAI>
 						</DOI>
 						<DOI name="RxCntGo">
-              <DAI esel:datasrc="db:PBRXGO" name="actVal" />
+							<DAI xmlns:esel="http://www.selinc.com/2006/61850" esel:datasrc="db:PBRXGO" name="actVal"/>
 							<DAI name="pulsQty">
 								<Val>1</Val>
 							</DAI>
 						</DOI>
 						<DOI name="RedRxCntGo">
@danyill danyill changed the title SCL edits with the Ace editor cause namespace problems. SCL edits with the Ace editor cause namespace problems Nov 26, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
1 participant
@danyill