Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Chromatically Tempered Sword and Flashrend are affected differently by Might of Stormwind #1115

Open
DaveAlessi opened this issue Oct 4, 2024 · 0 comments

Comments

@DaveAlessi
Copy link

DaveAlessi commented Oct 4, 2024

Describe the bug
Two sims with the same buffs, same consumes, same runes (holy and defense specialization), same rotations, and same gear (both Dwarves) have dramatically different DPS numbers when using Chromatically Tempered Sword vs. Flashrend.

I initially attributed this to CTS's and Flashrend's bonuses so I made them equivalent. I added 6 strength and 15 agility to the flashrend sim, while subtracting 1 melee and 1 spell crit. With these attribute changes the only difference between the two is swing speed (2.7 vs 2.8) dps (58.33 vs. 58.39) and base damage (110-205 vs. 114-213).

To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:
Create 2 identical sims, one with CTS and one with Flashrend and review DPS numbers

Expected behavior
Given how close these number are, I expected the DPS simulations to be close, with a slight advantage to Flashrend given it is slower and the gear uses the Paladin T2 Tanking 6-piece set bonus for extra swings. Without Might of Stormwind the numbers are close to what I expected, 1580 dps for Flashrend and 1563 for CTS. However, keeping everything else the same but adding the Might of stormwind buff, the numbers change dramatically. The CTS sim gains 189 dps from Might of Stormwind, while Flashrend only gains 32. I can see no reason why Might of Stormwind would affect CTS more than Flashrend, especially by such a huge margin.

Sim Links and Screenshots
Flashrend sim: https://wowsims.github.io/sod/retribution_paladin/#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

CTS sim: https://wowsims.github.io/sod/retribution_paladin/#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

CTS sim:
Screenshot 2024-10-04 133531

Flashrend sim with equalized stats:
Screenshot 2024-10-04 133550

Desktop (please complete the following information):
N/A

Smartphone (please complete the following information):
N/A

Additional context

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant