diff --git a/proto/deathknight.proto b/proto/deathknight.proto
index 658a5c4172..84420c1054 100644
--- a/proto/deathknight.proto
+++ b/proto/deathknight.proto
@@ -240,6 +240,8 @@ message Deathknight {
 		bool use_gargoyle = 23;
 
 		bool nerfed_gargoyle = 24;
+
+		Presence gargoyle_presence = 25;
 	}
 	Rotation rotation = 1;
 	
diff --git a/sim/deathknight/dps/dps_deathknight.go b/sim/deathknight/dps/dps_deathknight.go
index 90b8f80444..837c086922 100644
--- a/sim/deathknight/dps/dps_deathknight.go
+++ b/sim/deathknight/dps/dps_deathknight.go
@@ -108,6 +108,8 @@ func (dk *DpsDeathknight) SetupRotations() {
 			dk.Rotation.StartingPresence = proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Unholy
 			dk.Rotation.BlPresence = proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Blood
 			dk.Rotation.Presence = proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Blood
+			// TODO: Change this to UP presence if nerfedGargoyle is live
+			dk.Rotation.GargoylePresence = proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Blood
 
 			mh := dk.GetMHWeapon()
 			oh := dk.GetOHWeapon()
diff --git a/sim/deathknight/dps/rotation_unholy.go b/sim/deathknight/dps/rotation_unholy.go
index e7f3bd13a5..1d8edf701b 100644
--- a/sim/deathknight/dps/rotation_unholy.go
+++ b/sim/deathknight/dps/rotation_unholy.go
@@ -279,7 +279,7 @@ func (dk *DpsDeathknight) uhAfterGargoyleSequence(sim *core.Simulation) {
 			dk.RotationSequence.NewAction(dk.RotationActionCallback_AOTD)
 		}
 
-		if dk.Rotation.BlPresence == proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Blood && !dk.PresenceMatches(deathknight.BloodPresence) {
+		if dk.Rotation.BlPresence == proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Blood && !dk.PresenceMatches(deathknight.BloodPresence) && (!dk.Rotation.NerfedGargoyle || dk.Rotation.GargoylePresence == proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Blood) {
 			if didErw || dk.CurrentBloodRunes() > 0 {
 				dk.RotationSequence.NewAction(dk.RotationActionCallback_BP)
 			} else if !didErw && !dk.Rotation.BtGhoulFrenzy && dk.BloodTap.IsReady(sim) {
diff --git a/sim/deathknight/dps/rotation_unholy_helper.go b/sim/deathknight/dps/rotation_unholy_helper.go
index b347d10b5a..2dea9b285c 100644
--- a/sim/deathknight/dps/rotation_unholy_helper.go
+++ b/sim/deathknight/dps/rotation_unholy_helper.go
@@ -194,7 +194,7 @@ func (dk *DpsDeathknight) uhGargoyleCheck(sim *core.Simulation, target *core.Uni
 	}
 
 	if dk.uhGargoyleCanCast(sim, castTime) {
-		if !dk.PresenceMatches(deathknight.UnholyPresence) {
+		if !dk.PresenceMatches(deathknight.UnholyPresence) && (!dk.Rotation.NerfedGargoyle || dk.Rotation.GargoylePresence != proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Unholy) {
 			if dk.CurrentUnholyRunes() == 0 {
 				if dk.BloodTap.IsReady(sim) {
 					dk.BloodTap.Cast(sim, dk.CurrentTarget)
@@ -218,6 +218,27 @@ func (dk *DpsDeathknight) uhGargoyleCheck(sim *core.Simulation, target *core.Uni
 		}
 	}
 
+	// Go back to Blood Presence after Gargoyle
+	if dk.Rotation.NerfedGargoyle && !dk.SummonGargoyle.IsReady(sim) && dk.Rotation.Presence == proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Blood && dk.Rotation.GargoylePresence == proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Unholy && dk.PresenceMatches(deathknight.UnholyPresence) && !dk.HasActiveAura("Summon Gargoyle") {
+		if dk.BloodTapAura.IsActive() {
+			dk.BloodTapAura.Deactivate(sim)
+		}
+		return dk.BloodPresence.Cast(sim, target)
+	}
+
+	// Go back to Unholy Presence after Gargoyle
+	if dk.Rotation.NerfedGargoyle && !dk.SummonGargoyle.IsReady(sim) && dk.Rotation.Presence == proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Unholy && dk.Rotation.GargoylePresence == proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Blood && dk.PresenceMatches(deathknight.BloodPresence) && !dk.HasActiveAura("Summon Gargoyle") {
+		if dk.BloodTapAura.IsActive() {
+			dk.BloodTapAura.Deactivate(sim)
+		}
+		return dk.UnholyPresence.Cast(sim, target)
+	}
+
+	// Do not switch presences if gargoyle is still up if it's nerfed gargoyle
+	if dk.Rotation.NerfedGargoyle && dk.HasActiveAura("Summon Gargoyle") {
+		return false
+	}
+
 	// Go back to Blood Presence after Bloodlust
 	if dk.Rotation.Presence == proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Blood && dk.Rotation.BlPresence == proto.Deathknight_Rotation_Unholy && dk.PresenceMatches(deathknight.UnholyPresence) && !dk.HasActiveAuraWithTag("Bloodlust") {
 		if dk.BloodTapAura.IsActive() {
diff --git a/ui/deathknight/inputs.ts b/ui/deathknight/inputs.ts
index 32c84ef394..f4c56f5802 100644
--- a/ui/deathknight/inputs.ts
+++ b/ui/deathknight/inputs.ts
@@ -133,6 +133,18 @@ export const BloodlustPresence = InputHelpers.makeRotationEnumInput<Spec.SpecDea
 	changeEmitter: (player: Player<Spec.SpecDeathknight>) => TypedEvent.onAny([player.rotationChangeEmitter, player.talentsChangeEmitter]),
 });
 
+export const GargoylePresence = InputHelpers.makeRotationEnumInput<Spec.SpecDeathknight, StartingPresence>({
+	fieldName: 'gargoylePresence',
+	label: 'Gargoyle Presence',
+	labelTooltip: 'Presence during Gargoyle.',
+	values: [
+		{ name: 'Blood', value: StartingPresence.Blood },
+		{ name: 'Unholy', value: StartingPresence.Unholy },
+	],
+	showWhen: (player: Player<Spec.SpecDeathknight>) => player.getTalents().summonGargoyle && !player.getRotation().autoRotation,
+	changeEmitter: (player: Player<Spec.SpecDeathknight>) => TypedEvent.onAny([player.rotationChangeEmitter, player.talentsChangeEmitter]),
+});
+
 export const BloodTapGhoulFrenzy = InputHelpers.makeRotationBooleanInput<Spec.SpecDeathknight>({
 	fieldName: 'btGhoulFrenzy',
 	label: 'BT Ghoul Frenzy',
@@ -330,6 +342,7 @@ export const DeathKnightRotationConfig = {
 		FirstDiseaseInput,
 		StartingPresenceInput,
 		BloodlustPresence,
+		GargoylePresence,
 		FightPresence,
 		BloodRuneFillerInput,
 		UseDeathAndDecay,