diff --git a/sim/core/apl.go b/sim/core/apl.go
index 421c2b968d..fe2dd4a6ac 100644
--- a/sim/core/apl.go
+++ b/sim/core/apl.go
@@ -54,7 +54,7 @@ func (rot *APLRotation) doAndRecordWarnings(warningsList *[]string, isPrepull bo
 }
 
 func (unit *Unit) newAPLRotation(config *proto.APLRotation) *APLRotation {
-	if config == nil || !unit.IsUsingAPL {
+	if config == nil || config.Type != proto.APLRotation_TypeAPL {
 		return nil
 	}
 
diff --git a/sim/core/character.go b/sim/core/character.go
index 1017ef6de6..a238570052 100644
--- a/sim/core/character.go
+++ b/sim/core/character.go
@@ -106,10 +106,7 @@ func NewCharacter(party *Party, partyIndex int, player *proto.Player) Character
 			ChannelClipDelay:     max(0, time.Duration(player.ChannelClipDelayMs)*time.Millisecond),
 			DistanceFromTarget:   player.DistanceFromTarget,
 			NibelungAverageCasts: player.NibelungAverageCasts,
-			IsUsingAPL: player.Rotation != nil &&
-				(player.Rotation.Type == proto.APLRotation_TypeAPL ||
-					player.Rotation.Type == proto.APLRotation_TypeAuto ||
-					player.Rotation.Type == proto.APLRotation_TypeSimple),
+			IsUsingAPL:           player.Rotation != nil && player.Rotation.Type == proto.APLRotation_TypeAPL,
 		},
 
 		Name:  player.Name,
diff --git a/ui/core/player.ts b/ui/core/player.ts
index 468b69ac3b..257e3f7a6a 100644
--- a/ui/core/player.ts
+++ b/ui/core/player.ts
@@ -827,15 +827,11 @@ export class Player<SpecType extends Spec> {
 		const type = this.getRotationType();
 		if (type == APLRotationType.TypeAuto && this.autoRotationGenerator) {
 			// Clone to avoid modifying preset rotations, which are often returned directly.
-			const rot = APLRotation.clone(this.autoRotationGenerator(this));
-			rot.type = APLRotationType.TypeAuto;
-			return rot;
+			return APLRotation.clone(this.autoRotationGenerator(this));
 		} else if (type == APLRotationType.TypeSimple && this.simpleRotationGenerator) {
 			// Clone to avoid modifying preset rotations, which are often returned directly.
-			const simpleRot = this.getRotation();
-			const rot = APLRotation.clone(this.simpleRotationGenerator(this, simpleRot, this.getCooldowns()));
-			rot.simple = this.aplRotation.simple;
-			rot.type = APLRotationType.TypeSimple; // Set this here for convenience, so the generator functions don't need to.
+			const rot = APLRotation.clone(this.simpleRotationGenerator(this, this.getRotation(), this.getCooldowns()));
+			rot.type = APLRotationType.TypeAPL; // Set this here for convenience, so the generator functions don't need to.
 			return rot;
 		} else {
 			return this.aplRotation;