Skip to content

Commit

Permalink
Simplification: single set of review checks (no "lightweight" review)
Browse files Browse the repository at this point in the history
  • Loading branch information
marco-tiloca-sics committed Jan 30, 2025
1 parent cfae6b1 commit d9dd123
Showing 1 changed file with 8 additions and 12 deletions.
20 changes: 8 additions & 12 deletions draft-ietf-core-cf-reg-update.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -158,10 +158,10 @@ The CoAP Content-Formats registration procedures defined in {{Section 12.3 of -c

| Range | Registration Procedures | Note |
|--------|--------|
| 0-255 | Expert Review | Full review described in {{&SELF}}, {{full-checks}} |
| 256-9999 | IETF Review with Expert Review or IESG Approval with Expert Review | Full review described in {{&SELF}}, {{full-checks}} |
| 0-255 | Expert Review | Review checks described in {{&SELF}}, {{checks}} |
| 256-9999 | IETF Review with Expert Review or IESG Approval with Expert Review | Review checks described in {{&SELF}}, {{checks}} |
| 10000-64999 (No parameters and empty Content Coding and media type not yet used in this registry) | First Come First Served | The corresponding media type must be registered (or approved for publication) in the "Media Types" registry {{IANA.media-types}} |
| 10000-64999 (Includes parameters and/or Content Coding and/or media type appears in this registry) | Expert Review | Lightweight review described in {{&SELF}}, {{checks}} |
| 10000-64999 (Includes parameters and/or Content Coding and/or media type appears in this registry) | Expert Review | Review checks described in {{&SELF}}, {{checks}} |
| 65000-65535 | Experimental use (no operational use) |
{: #tbl-new-cf-proc title="Updated CoAP Content-Formats Registration Procedures"}

Expand All @@ -179,22 +179,18 @@ In all other cases, the policy will be Expert Review, following the checklist de

A new column with the title "Note" has been added to the registry, which contains information about expected checks.

## "Full" Expert Review Checks {#full-checks}
## Expert Review Checks {#checks}

For the 0-255 range and the 256-9999 range, the DE is instructed to perform a "Full Review" described in this section, not only the "lightweight" Expert Review that may apply to the 10000-64999 range.

For the 0-255 range, in addition to the checks described in {{checks}}, the DE is instructed to also evaluate the requested codepoint concerning the limited availability of the 1-byte codepoint space.
For the 256-9999 range and the 10000-64999 range, this criterion does not apply.

## "Lightweight" Expert Review Checks {#checks}

For the 10000-64999 range, the Designated Expert is instructed to perform the "lightweight" Expert review, as described by the following checklist:
The Designated Expert is instructed to perform the Expert Review, as described by the following checklist:

1. The combination of content-type and content coding for which the registration is requested must not be already present in the "CoAP Content-Formats" registry;
1. The media type associated with the requested Content-Format must exist (or must have been approved for registration) in the "Media Types" registry {{IANA.media-types}};
1. The optional parameter names must have been defined in association with the media type, and any parameter values associated with such parameter names must be as permitted;
1. If a Content Coding is specified, it must exist (or must have been approved for registration) in the "HTTP Content Coding" registry of the "Hypertext Transfer Protocol (HTTP) Parameters" {{IANA.http-parameters}}.

For the 0-255 range, in addition to the checks described above, the DE is instructed to also evaluate the requested codepoint concerning the limited availability of the 1-byte codepoint space.
For the 256-9999 range and the 10000-64999 range, this criterion does not apply.

<!-- Should these actually use BCP14 MUSTs? -->

## Temporary Note Removal
Expand Down

0 comments on commit d9dd123

Please sign in to comment.